State Taxes and the April Surprise

By :: July 22nd, 2014

In recent months, several governors have complained about the April, 2014, surprise in state tax revenues. They say they were shocked when personal income tax payments fell far below expectations. They shouldn’t have been.

What happened? In part, in an effort to beat an upcoming increase in capital gains taxes, investors accelerated realizations into tax year 2012, artificially increasing their tax payments in April, 2013. Most state revenue estimators recognized the bump but a few used the high base and forecast continued high payments again in 2014. That windfall did not happen and those states were faced with embarrassing shortfalls.

There are some surprises every April 15th, as taxpayers settle up with both the IRS and those states with a personal income tax. Sometimes the surprise is pleasant, like last year, and sometimes ugly, like this year.

But it should not have been so shocking. Investors timing asset sales in response to changes in capital gains tax rates is hardly new. And they often exacerbate swings caused by a changing stock market.

First a little background. In 2012, federal tax law was filled with temporary extensions from 2010 expirations of tax cuts including a preferential capital gains tax rate. In addition, the 2010 Affordable Care Act also raised taxes on capital gains for some investors. As a result, taxpayers shifted capital gains realizations into 2012 to avoid higher federal taxes. If this sounds familiar, it happened in 1986.

Add to that a strong stock market rebound and those April 2013 returns reported a lot more capital gains than anyone expected. The Congressional Budget Office reported that federal income tax collections were 20 percent higher in April, 2013 than April, 2012.

The same thing happened in the states, where individual income tax revenue in the second quarter of 2013 was 18.4 percent higher than the same period in 2012. (California alone was responsible for about 2 percentage points of the growth –not only did it raise its top tax rates in 2012 but it also raked in a pile of tax as residents took profits from Facebook’s initial public offering).

The real surprise came this past April when income tax revenues tanked as final payments came in well below forecast.  A few states got it right. Ohio projected a loss of about 17 percent (because of tax cuts in addition to the capital gains shift) and was pretty happy when income tax only fell 15 percent.  Same with California where the underestimate of income tax led to the first year end surplus since 2007.  But a lot of states projected income tax growth and came up empty. Some, like New Jersey, were way off the mark.

For the estimate of capital gains, the strong market in 2013 (the SP500 was up 19 percent) was the main reason for optimism.  For example, Arizona’s estimators recognized the shift in capital gains, reducing revenue by $52 million over three years but added revenue because of the strong 2013 market performance. Maryland’s Board of Revenue Estimates told a similar story: a strong stock market and rebounding housing market offset the shift in capital gains. Both states ended up with much less income tax than they had planned for.

Fortunately, Congress isn’t making any big tax changes this year so state economists can take the opportunity to improve their models.  But the feds have not eschewed short term tax gimmicks –pension smoothing anyone? So state revenue forecasters will still need to understand how taxpayers react to uncertain tax rules, both federal and state.


  1. Ralph H  ::  10:28 am on July 22nd, 2014:

    Typically state officials are not rocket scientists and subject to political pressures. For example, pre 2008 NJ added 5 years to teacher’s service for a year because their state pension plan was OVERFUNDED. We all know how that turned out and now it is chronically under funded as are most state pensions.

    We continue to ignore the laws of economics at the state, municipal and federal level. I bet we will regret it in the future when we have to take much more dollars out of the budget to pay high short term rates. At that time it will be a crises and we will blame the then current politicians, not the folks currently running deficits or using borrowing gimmicks.

  2. AMTbuff  ::  2:44 pm on July 22nd, 2014:

    Government agencies are adept at ignoring inconvenient truths. When their jobs and the continuation of their spending policies require rosy revenue estimates, the estimates will be rosy. The “surprise” then becomes an excuse for a tax increase.

    I am surprised that the author would find any of this surprising.

  3. Michael Bindner  ::  2:57 am on July 23rd, 2014:

    The effect of the coming revenue increases was apparent to anyone watching the stock market fluctuate in the fall of 2012 as people took profits. Back then, it was risky – because if Obama had caved to Republican demands to preserve all the Bush cuts (and stop the ACA ones), the tax increase wold not have happened – no matter how much the Senator from the Club for Growth – I mean the Junior Senator from Pennsylvania demanded just that. Instead, the famous January 2nd deal happened so that scoring calls keeping the cuts for the bottom 98% a tax cut, rather than the increase to the top 2% a tax increase. Even then, Tea Party members did not vote for it in the House – but with the Hastert rule suspended it went to the floor anyway and passed.

    It is not all states that are in trouble this year – only those who have a Republican Party government who cut taxes whenever possible – even though they are historically low. If there were such thing as a Laffer Curve (in reality, it is a fairy tale), this would not be the time to do it and expect more revenue. Sadly, the culture wars like will prevent any of our big tax cutters from being held responsible for their folly. That is a shame.

  4. celebrity evening dresses 2014  ::  6:44 am on July 23rd, 2014:

    In simple words, fashion illustration gives a freedom to the
    artist to put forward the fashion designs and ideas in front of the entire world.
    Laughter, smiles and playfulness were the norm for
    his photos, but it was not in fashion photography.
    Almost every day we are exposed to the damaging effects
    of the ultraviolet rays that are sometimes high
    in radiation.

    Here is my blog :: celebrity evening dresses 2014

  5. CAPITAL GAINS RATE TABLE 2014  ::  8:04 pm on July 25th, 2014:

    […] TaxVox » blog Archive State Taxes and the April shock » TaxVox […]

  6. nadia – medios de comunicacion  ::  10:55 am on August 12th, 2014:

    Hello there!
    I fall in love with your post is super!
    I served much a theme for an exhibition of school, thanks :)

  7. Allie  ::  9:51 pm on August 19th, 2014:

    What’s it take to become a sublime exudnpoer of prose like yourself?

  8. social media marketing plan xls  ::  6:45 am on August 22nd, 2014:

    Take initiative and get the amount of customers you deserve.
    Promote multiple affiliate programs in your website but don’t promote
    every little thing the world has to offer. There are many different features like your own profile, blogging updates, Street
    Talk, the ability to comment and like Street Articles Facebook page, Street Articles Google + page, Street Articles Twitter Page, and the ability to interact with the owners (not to
    a great extent, they are quite busy).

    Feel free to surf to my web blog: social media marketing plan xls

  9. celebrity dress size 10  ::  12:59 am on August 23rd, 2014:

    And to add variation to it Beckham splits that into a third
    ponytail up high flowing into the traditional half pony tail.
    Vintage jewelry was the charm and retro designs mixed with modern looks were another hit style in jewelry.
    Which will lessen the opportunity of producing blunders.

    Here is my site celebrity dress size 10

  10. Custom teak marine food freezer boxes  ::  8:59 pm on August 29th, 2014:

    Everyone wants cheap bait these days but the big problem is
    that cheap often means rubbish. After users select
    their avatar they’re transported into their apartment.
    You can then take your armored vehicle and cash it in at a chop shop,
    creating a nice little criminal spree combo.

    Here is my blog :: Custom teak marine food freezer boxes

  11. marine refrigerator transmission repair maryville tn  ::  1:59 am on September 15th, 2014:

    Everyone wants cheap bait these days but the big problem is that cheap often means rubbish.
    At times, your sailing instructor may need to issue an order and have it followed immediately.
    But have you ever thought about living in your boat full time.

    Stop by my webpage: marine refrigerator transmission repair maryville tn

  12. Nathan Scheer  ::  9:17 pm on October 18th, 2014:

    Wonderful blog! Do you have any tips for aspiring writers?
    I’m hoping to start my own site soon but I’m a little lost oon everything.
    Would you propose starting with a free platform like WordPress or go for a paid
    option? There are so manyy options out there that I’m totally overwhelmed ..
    Any recommendations? Thank you!

  13. life insurance company  ::  2:52 pm on February 13th, 2015:

    Kudos to you! I hadn’t thought of that!

  14. auto insurance  ::  5:44 am on February 19th, 2015:

    That’s a smart answer to a difficult question.

  15. sildenafil  ::  6:20 pm on February 24th, 2015:

    I’m not easily impressed but you’ve done it with that posting.