CBO’s Spending Projections Map the Coming Fiscal Battle

Without changes in the law, health care, Social Security, and interest on the debt will eat up 85 percent of all new federal government spending over the next 10 years, according to the latest estimates by the Congressional Budget Office. By contrast, CBO expects most of the rest of government, including income security for low-income households, national defense, transportation, health and safety, education, and the like to shrink to its lowest levels—as a share of the economy—since before World War II.

Combined, all of government—except for health care, Social Security, and net interest—will absorb only about 7.4 percent of Gross Domestic Product by 2024, down by one-fifth from 2013 and one-third lower than it was in the mid-1970s.

CBO spending 8-14

 

Total spending would remain close to the 40-year average of about 21 percent of GDP, despite an aging population that will require more medical care and receive, in aggregate, much more in Social Security benefits. And despite annual interest costs that CBO figures will rise from $230 billion this year to almost $800 billion in a decade, or from 1.3 percent of GDP to 3 percent.

While CBO’s updated deficit forecast got most of the attention (if you missed it: the short-term deficit is due to shrink, thanks mostly to a rebounding economy), the more interesting story is what is expected to happen to federal spending under current law.

If Republicans win control of the Senate and retain dominance in the House, don’t be surprised to see a fundamental battle over spending beginning next spring. Remember, for many in Congress, the deficit isn’t the issue. It is the size of government.

Taxes, which have been the focus of so many past fiscal wars, may very well take a back seat over the next couple of years. Comprehensive tax reform seems largely off the table until at least after the next presidential election. And it is hard to see the GOP pushing for big tax cuts in 2015.

Think of the CBO report as a map of the coming field of battle. As always, the budget agency’s projections assume current law. That means the sequester’s automatic spending cuts for much of government resume as scheduled after fiscal 2015. Without those cuts, spending would be $874 billion higher over the next decade (plus $156 billion in interest on the added debt).

While Medicaid, Social Security, and a few other programs are exempt from those deep spending cuts, nearly everything else is not. It is a vision of government that will squeeze out many Democratic priorities, yet is only a starting point for many Republicans. It is already easy to see where the pressure points will come when Congress and President Obama once again square off over spending. And keep in mind: If Congress does not act (often the safest bet), the cuts in the CBO baseline will happen.

One example: The Pentagon is due for deep cuts under the sequester, but will they still be acceptable to lawmakers of either party given recent events in Syria, Iraq, and Ukraine? If the Pentagon gets more, will Republicans try to make up the difference by cutting domestic spending even more deeply?

Behind the raw numbers, CBO’s fiscal update describes a very different government than we’ve come to expect. Beyond providing health care and Social Security and paying ever-more interest on the growing debt, government and the services it provides are scheduled to shrink, and perhaps by quite a lot.

Is this what a majority of voters really want? I’m not sure, but we may be about to find out.


Could The U.S. Fix Taxation of Multinational Corporations With A Sales-Based Formula?

Corporate inversions have been the topic of the summer for tax wonks (beats jellyfish and beach traffic, I suppose), but the issue is a classic bit of Washington misdirection. Instead of focusing on the real disease—an increasingly dysfunctional corporate income tax—we are obsessing over a symptom—firms such as Burger King engaging in self-help reform by […]


Tax Rates: Growth, Competition, and Debt

Congress is in recess until September 8. The Daily Deduction will next appear on Tuesday, September 2. It will resume its regular schedule on Monday, September 8. Individual tax rates: If you cut them, what will grow? Representative Paul Ryan, who is likely to become the next chair of  the House Ways and Means Committee, wants […]


How Much Would An Individual Tax Rate Cut Add to the Deficit, and Who Would Benefit?

Reducing tax rates is a guiding principal of most tax reform plans. Even Democrats who see reform partly as a tool to boost revenues agree that some money generated by eliminating tax preferences ought to go to rate reduction. But how much does Treasury lose when Congress reduces individual tax rates, and which taxpayers benefit the […]


One Downside Of Inversions: Higher Tax Bills For Stockholders

Corporate inversions are all the rage these days as U.S. businesses merge with foreign firms and then restructure the combined businesses as foreign-based corporations. That yields tax benefits and may boost their after-tax profits, but it can also leave their stockholders with unwanted capital gains and big tax bills. As Howard Gleckman explained in TaxVox […]


Is Treasury About to Curb Tax Inversions on Its Own?

The Treasury Department put out the word that Secretary Jack Lew is considering regulatory curbs on corporate tax inversions, a step that may be intended to increase pressure on Congress to act once it returns from its summer recess in September. The matter of how much authority Treasury has to limit inversions has generated its […]


Do Sales Tax Holidays Ever Make Sense?

Politicians love sales tax holidays as good campaign fodder. Retailers celebrate them with gaudy signs announcing tax-free shopping, and consumers line up to take advantage of the deals. But economists and policy analysts across the ideological spectrum condemn them as poorly targeted tax policy that produces little economic benefit. Is there any fiscal justification for […]


Use It or Lose It: The Authority to Tax, or Not

Congress is in recess. The Daily Deduction will return to its regular schedule on Monday, September 8. Until then: We’ll see you every Monday morning. Don’t like corporate inversions? If the Administration wants to stop them, it can. TPC’s Steve Rosenthal explains: Treasury has the authority to treat a corporation’s interest payments on debt to […]


Can Obama slow corporate inversions? Yes he can.

Politicians can debate whether corporate tax inversions are “unpatriotic” or simply a legitimate technique to reduce taxes–and commentators can argue over whether anything should be done to stop them. Experts also disagree about whether President Obama and his Treasury Secretary have the legal authority to write new rules to discourage inversions. In my view, on this last […]


August Avoidance: Corporate Taxes and Budget Realities

Congress is in recess. The Daily Deduction will return to its regular schedule on Monday, September 8. Until then: We’ll see you every Monday morning.  Walgreen might be the only one who’s tired of talking about inversions. The Illinois-based drugstore chain plans to keep its tax base in the US after purchasing Alliance Boots. But […]