An Updated Marriage Bonus and Penalty Calculator for Valentine’s Day

By :: February 13th, 2013

Love is blind, says the adage, and that can be a good thing when it comes to taxes. That’s because married couples often pay a marriage penalty—a higher federal income tax bill than they would if they were single. But for most couples, marriage means a lower tax bill—a marriage bonus in tax-speak.

Just in time for Valentine’s Day, the Tax Policy Center has updated its marriage bonus and penalty calculator to reflect the provisions of the American Taxpayer Relief Act of 2012 (ATRA), the new tax law Congress passed earlier this year. The new calculator lets you compare the tax bills of a couple filing as singles and as a couple for either the 2012 or 2013 tax year.

My TaxVox post about TPC’s original marriage bonus and penalty calculator explained why the tax code rewards some married couples and penalizes others so I won’t repeat all of that here. Instead I’ll discuss three tax provisions that will increase marriage penalties a lot in 2013 for many high-income couples.

1. ATRA’s new top tax rate: ATRA created a new 39.6 percent top tax bracket, which starts at $400,000 for single filers and $450,000 for couples filing jointly. Consider two people, each with $400,000 of taxable income. Unmarried, neither would hit the 39.6 percent rate. Married, they would pay the top rate on $350,000. That and other rate effects would impose a marriage penalty of more than $30,000.

2. Return of  PEP and Pease: ATRA reinstated both the phaseout of personal exemptions (PEP) and the limitation on itemized deductions (Pease) that the 2001-2010 tax acts had eliminated. PEP takes away 2 percent of personal exemptions for each $2,500 (or part thereof) above a threshold—$250,000 of adjusted gross income (AGI) for singles and $300,000 for couples (both indexed for inflation going forward). PEP wouldn’t affect an unmarried couple in which each person has $250,000 of AGI but would take away all of their personal exemptions if they were married. That could increase their tax bill by more than $1,500 for each person in their family.

Pease reduces itemized deductions by 3 percent of AGI over the same thresholds that apply for PEP. It wouldn’t affect the unmarried couple with each person having $250,000 of AGI, but would raise their taxable income by up to $6,000 if they married, adding as much as $2,376 to their tax bill.

3. Obamacare Taxes: Two new taxes associated with the 2010 healthcare acts take effect in 2013: a 0.9 percent tax on earnings over unindexed thresholds—$200,000 for singles and $250,000 for couples—and a 3.8 percent tax on investment income over those thresholds. Two people earning $200,000 apiece would owe neither tax. If they marry, they would pay between $1,350 (if their income is all wages) and $5,700 (if it’s all investment income) in new taxes to support Obamacare.

The calculator makes it easy to determine these and other tax consequences of marriage in 2013. That’s not a very romantic activity, however, and, speaking as a happily married man, I suggest you find a better way to spend Valentine’s Day.


  1. Michael Bindner  ::  9:22 pm on February 13th, 2013:

    The rate effects are what I find interesting, especially in regard to capital gains and dividends. PEP, Pease and ACA essentially turn these rates to 25% (according to a previous TAXVOX posting). If such a family pays a 25% marginal tax rate on earned income as well and holds onto corporate stock which is expert at tax avoidance, they are essentially paying a 25% flat tax. This interesting set of facts makes tax reform more likely, since we still seem to be hitting the same rate range, although there may be a need for higher surtaxes for the really high income earners and heirs as well as some type of VAT that everyone pays. This latest round of reforms illustrates that we may be actually moving more toward common sense than away from.

  2. Blog Archive » An Updated Marriage Bonus and Penalty Calculator … « Tax Rate Calculator  ::  7:53 am on February 14th, 2013:

    […] Blog Archive » An Updated Marriage Bonus and Penalty Calculator … […]

  3. Tax Roundup, 2/14/2013: Happy Valentine’s Day! Oh, and tell me more about your illegal tax shelter, honey! « Roth & Company, P.C  ::  10:47 am on February 14th, 2013:

    […] you are thinking of proposing tonight, check out An Updated Marriage Bonus and Penalty Calculator for Valentine’s Day from Roberton Williams at TaxVox before you […]

  4. An Updated Marriage Bonus and Penalty Calculator for Valentine's … « Tax Rate Calculator  ::  2:47 pm on May 24th, 2013:

    […] An Updated Marriage Bonus and Penalty Calculator for Valentine's … […]

  5. Look who’s paying the marriage penalty this year  ::  11:28 am on February 25th, 2014:

    […] because the provisions are mainly geared toward people who make a lot of money. One provision is aimed only at earnings […]

  6. Leora  ::  10:43 pm on March 5th, 2014:

    I know this web page gives quality based content and other stuff, is there any other site which presents these kinds of
    things in quality?

    Here is my webpage; SEO (Leora)

  7. Finance For Non-finance Managers Training In Malaysia | Get Financial Stability In Your Life  ::  2:20 pm on August 9th, 2014:

    […] Training In Malaysia annual tax deduction will go up as well. You?re knocking time off the mortgage calculation tool compares the figures generated by putting a $100,000 mortgage is ga chapter 7 bankruptcy exemptions a […]

  8. Marriage Quotes From The Bible  ::  10:13 pm on October 23rd, 2014:

    Marriage Quotes From The Bible