The very unRepublican Small Business Tax Cut

By :: April 24th, 2012

My Tax Policy Center colleague Eric Toder and I are mystified by how unRepublican the House GOP’s Small Business Tax Cut Act really is. Sure, cutting taxes for businesses and high-income individuals is very much part of the Republican playbook these days. But the mechanics of this one seem to fly in the face of what many in the party have been saying lately.

The bill would allow both C corporations and pass-through businesses with fewer than 500 employees to deduct 20 percent of their income from federal income tax for one year. The proposal was wrapped in rhetoric about job-creators and small businesses. But, in fact, it is exactly the sort of anti free-market, short-term industrial policy that Republicans rightly decry when Democrats try it.

To see how, let’s pull the bill apart:

It favors some businesses over others: By limiting its definition of eligible businesses to fewer than 500 workers, this bill would penalize firms that rely on labor instead of capital—quite the opposite of what you’d expect from a jobs-creating bill.

For instance, the measure would benefit hedge funds, real estate partnerships, and law firms—many of which are unlikely to hire many more workers as a result of the new tax break.

Even Mitt Romney’s former investment firm Bain Capital might be eligible for this “small business” subsidy. Although it manages an estimated $66 billion, Bain employees only 400 professionals. With a lean enough support staff, it might be one of those lucky small businesses.  

The bill would also reward established, profitable firms rather than new, fast-growing businesses that have little taxable income and would be less likely to benefit from a new deduction.  

It encourages franchises and spin-offs rather than direct hiring. While the bill includes some anti-gaming rules, these often can be successfully manipulated. As a result, firms will find ways to benefit from the tax cut merely by changing the way they organize themselves—choices that do nothing to increase employment or economic growth.     

In effect, two firms with the same amount of gross receipts would be taxed differently for reasons that seem completely arbitrary.  Of course, this happens all the time today. But why make it worse? The GOP rightly criticizes government for picking winners and losers. That’s exactly what this bill would do.

It is a temporary tax cut. Last year, the GOP ripped Democrats for temporarily extending the payroll tax cut. Temporary tax cuts, Republicans argued, do little to boost economic growth. So why did they propose this tax cut for only one year?

Probably for the same reasons Democrats do—so it would appear to increase the deficit by far less than it likely will. The Joint Committee on Taxation estimates the bill would add $46 billion in red ink over 10 years. But in reality, it would add nearly all of it in the first two years (it would take two because of the difference between the government’s fiscal year and the tax years of most companies).

I'm willing to bet this “temporary” tax cut would become just one more in the long list of tax extenders that never die. So the real 10-year cost would not be $46 billion, but hundreds of billions more.  

If the tax cut really is temporary, many of the perverse effects I’m complaining about might not occur. For instance, most companies would not change their corporate form to take advantage of a one year tax break. Of course, a temporary  tax cut would also be less likely to create any new jobs and instead would be pure windfall to eligible firms.

On top of all of this, TPC finds the measure would overwhelmingly benefit high-income households and do almost nothing for the middle-class.   

As everyone knows, this bill will die in the Senate. Thus, it is said, House Republicans wanted to pass it to send a political message. Perhaps, but as public policy, this plan is awfully lame.              



  1. Michael Bindner  ::  10:25 pm on April 24th, 2012:

    Tax cuts are not what we need. We need comprehensive reform, which would include higher rates for dividends and capital gains so that CEOs don’t have a personal stake in cutting labor costs for self-enrichment. Labor costs are now so low and so constrained that even an accomodating monetary policy cannot make up for the lack of consumer demand among workers. The Great Recession pretty much ended the ability to do that.

  2. Tax Roundup, 4/25/2012 « Roth & Company, P.C  ::  9:55 am on April 25th, 2012:

    […] Tax Gimmickry has friends in both parties: The very unRepublican Small Business Tax Cut (TaxVox) […]

  3. barbour  ::  9:22 pm on April 26th, 2012:

    In sixteen twenty-one, a big celebration of barbour jacket took place at Plymouth Colony in what is now the state of Massachusetts. European settlers known as the barbour jackets were celebrating their autumn harvest after a winter of struggle.
    Other colonists held earlier ceremonies of thanks. But the Pilgrims’ three-day feast is often called the nation’s first barbour outlet Thanksgiving. President Abraham Lincoln declared a national holiday in eighteen sixty-three during the Civil War.
    Today families and friends gather on the fourth Thursday in November. And, thanks to the barbour quilted jacket United States Census Bureau, here are some facts about where their Thanksgiving meal comes from.
    The main dish is traditionally a turkey. About two-thirds of the nation’s turkeys are produced in Minnesota and five other quilted barbour jackets tates. Producers are expected to raise two hundred forty-eight million birds this year, two percent more than last year.
    Popular side dishes include cranberries and sweet potatoes. Last year North Carolina barbour sale grew more sweet potatoes than any other state. Wisconsin is expected to be the top cranberry producer this year.
    People often finish the meal with pumpkin pie. Last year Illinois grew the most pumpkins. California, New York, Ohio and barbour uk were also major pumpkin producers.
    Thanksgiving is a big event, but buying a barbour mens traditional holiday meal can be a struggle for the poor. So charity groups often hold food drives to collect food forbarbour ladies low-income families.

  4. coast  ::  9:33 pm on April 26th, 2012:

    Coast Dresses are an excellent high street brand if you are in the market for the perfect special occasion dress.
    Whether you have a ball/prom, a black tie event, a wedding or just a special night out with the girls Coast have something suitable for all different occasions.
    Coast are one of the top brands for formal and evening occasionwear and they have several awards to prove it.The styles of Coast UK range from long maxi designs to knee length frocks to suit different evening events.
    Coast Clothes outfits are available in UK dress size 6 to 18 and a range of materials from duchess satin to silk taffeta.
    From the very start their mission has been to provide beautiful top quality Coast Dress for all the special events throughout your life,and they sure don’t disappoint.

    Coast Sale have a passion for all that is elegant,beautiful and unique.They are dedicated to creating fresh new in-house designs which enable women to look and feel glamorous.

    Coast has the collection of Coast Bridal Dresses,Coast Halter Dresses,Coast One Shoulder Dress,Coast Shoulders Dresses and Coast Strapless Dresses.

  5. sale_007  ::  2:49 am on April 27th, 2012:

    Few watch aficionados realize that the Japanese brand seiko watch has a history as old as many of its Swiss rivals. Founded in the 1880s, the company began manufacturing wrist seiko watches after World War I and quickly became an innovative leader, developing one of the world’s first seiko automatic and seiko chronograph. But perhaps Seiko’s greatest achievement came about in its race with the American brand Bulova to harness new technology, leading to the quartz watch, which revolutionized the industry and nearly drove the Swiss out of business.
    More innovations followed, including the first computer wristwatch, in 1984, and the first nonbattery seiko kinetic watch. To this list we can now add another groundbreaker: the Seiko Spring Drive mechanical movement, which is accurate to one second per day, making it approximately three times more precise than the average mechanical watch. The Spring Drive also provides an enduring seventy-two hours of power reserve (most watches offer about forty) and winds 30 percent faster than a conventional movement.
    According to seiko uk, twenty-eight years of work went into developing this movement, and only five of the company’s hundreds of watchmakers possess the requisite skills to assemble it. Regardless of its technological history, the seiko 5 is a skillfully designed watch, with graceful hands and interesting use of off-center dials.

  6. Around The Dial – April 27, 2012 | South By North Strategies, Ltd.  ::  3:07 pm on April 27th, 2012:

    […] TaxVox finds the GOP’s proposed small business ta cut to be very un-GOP. […]

  7. TaxVox’s 2012 Lump of Coal Awards | About Income Taxes  ::  4:17 pm on January 9th, 2013:

    […] The House Republicans’ Small Business Tax Cut Act. When sensible, the GOP says it favors permanent tax policy that keeps government out of the […]

  8. Immigration Advice Westminister  ::  4:37 pm on March 24th, 2013:

    Hello! I could have sworn I’ve been to this website before but after looking at some of the posts I realized it’s new to me.
    Anyhow, I’m definitely delighted I found it and I’ll be book-marking it and checking back often!

    my web page; Immigration Advice Westminister

  9. Visiting religious workers Visa  ::  9:10 pm on April 29th, 2013:

    Hi! Quick question that’s totally off topic. Do you know how to make your site mobile friendly? My web site looks weird when browsing from my apple iphone. I’m trying to find a theme or plugin that might be able
    to correct this issue. If you have any suggestions,
    please share. Thanks!

  10.  ::  6:26 am on August 6th, 2014:

    TaxVox » Blog Archive The very unRepublican Small Business Tax Cut » TaxVox

  11.  ::  6:05 am on August 8th, 2014:

    TaxVox » Blog Archive The very unRepublican Small Business Tax Cut » TaxVox

  12. pictures of cheap mothers day flower arrangements  ::  8:49 pm on August 8th, 2014:

    pictures of cheap mothers day flower arrangements

    TaxVox » Blog Archive The very unRepublican Small Business Tax Cut » TaxVox

  13.  ::  10:03 pm on August 8th, 2014:

    TaxVox » Blog Archive The very unRepublican Small Business Tax Cut » TaxVox

  14.  ::  3:11 pm on August 12th, 2014:

    TaxVox » Blog Archive The very unRepublican Small Business Tax Cut » TaxVox

  15. clothing  ::  11:39 am on August 13th, 2014:


    TaxVox » Blog Archive The very unRepublican Small Business Tax Cut » TaxVox

  16.  ::  2:27 am on August 17th, 2014:

    TaxVox » Blog Archive The very unRepublican Small Business Tax Cut » TaxVox

  17. find find cheap package holidays  ::  8:13 am on September 24th, 2014:

    find find cheap package holidays


  18. better than  ::  3:12 pm on October 6th, 2014:

    better than


  19. Wolky Jewel Sandals  ::  10:35 pm on October 10th, 2014:

    Thank you a lot for sharing this with all of us you actually recognise what you’re speaking approximately!
    Bookmarked. Please also discuss with my web site =). We can have a hyperlink alternaate
    arrangement between us

  20. mens suits  ::  3:44 pm on October 12th, 2014:

    mens suits


  21. Tiwiki-Design.Com  ::  10:44 am on October 13th, 2014:



  22. here are the findings  ::  5:42 pm on October 19th, 2014:

    here are the findings