The “Helping Working Families Afford Child Care Act” Would Help, but Doesn’t Solve the Timing Mismatch

By :: July 28th, 2014

The Child and Dependent Care Tax Credit (CDCTC) does not work for low-income families. It fails on three counts – the credit is nonrefundable, covers only a portion of expenses, and comes long after expenses have been incurred.

Senators Jeanne Shaheen (D-NH), Barbara Boxer (D-CA), Patty Murray (D-WA), and Kristin Gillibrand (D-NY) have proposed the Helping Working Families Afford Child Care Act to address the first two problems. The bill would also limit benefits for families with incomes in excess of $200,000. The Tax Policy Center ­estimates the bill would cost about $38 billion over the 10-year budget window from 2015–2024. It’s a great start for helping low-income families pay for child care. A better option would be one that delivers benefits contemporaneous with expenses.

The Senate bill would allow families to receive a refundable 20 percent credit for childcare expenses of up to $8,000 per child ($16,000 max per family). That translates to a credit of up to $1,600 ($3,200 for families with more than one child). Because the credit would be refundable, low-income families would get the full value they qualify for, rather than only that part of the credit that offsets the taxes they owe. That’s important for low-income families, most of whom do not pay federal income tax.

Under current law, families with income of $43,000 or less qualify for up to a 35 percent credit on as much as $3,000 of child care expenses ($6,000 per family). But very few people fully benefit from the higher credit rate because they have little or no tax liability. A 20 percent refundable credit would be worth far more, particularly when coupled with increasing allowable expenses (see table).

Comparison of Current Law Child and Dependent Care Tax Credit and Helping Working Families Afford Child Care Act, 2015

Current Law Helping Working Families Afford Child Care Act
Maximum Expenses $3,000 per child; $6,000 per family $8,000 per child; $16,000 per family
Credit Rate 20 – 35%; lowest rate applies once income exceeds $43,000. 20%
Phase out? No Yes. Credit phases out between $200,000 - $290,000 of AGI.
Refundable? No Yes
Indexed for inflation? No Yes

Source: Urban-Brookings Tax Policy Center and

In 2015, the TPC estimates that the CDCTC will deliver $3.7 billion in benefits to 6.6 million families. Under the proposal, $6.9 billion would go to 8.4 million families. Average benefits would increase from $563 to $822 – but some lower-income groups would see much larger average increases (see figure). Under current law, almost no families with incomes below $10,000 can benefit from the CDCTC. Because the proposed credit is refundable, 140,000 families would receive an average benefit of $728. For families with incomes between $10,000 and $20,000, the number of beneficiary families would rise from 26,000 to 764,000 – and average benefits would quadruple from $153 to $630.

Higher income families would also get larger credits under the proposal because of the increase in the maximum allowable expenses. Very high income families, however, would see their average benefits drop because the credit phases out. Families with income between $500,000 and $1 million would see their average credits fall from $560 to $292; the number of families with benefits in that income range would decline from 51,000 to 1,000. Families with even higher incomes would lose their credits entirely. (Note that our tables are based on an expanded income measure, which tends to be higher than AGI, the income concept used to determine eligibility.)


The proposal would complicate childcare benefits for families with one child, just as they are already complicated for families with more than one child who can benefit from both dependent care spending accounts and the CDCTC. This problem could be fixed if the dependent case spending account limits were the same as the CDCTC limits – or if dependent care spending accounts were eliminated.

Even if this bill became law, low-income families would still face the problem of paying their childcare bills. They typically have to pay when services are performed, generally long before tax benefits show up in tax refunds, a major problem for people facing cash-flow constraints.

Congress could address that problem by expanding funding for direct childcare subsidies rather than increasing the credit. Government has experience delivering monthly benefits and it better fits the cash flow needs of many families. In spite of this shortcoming, the Senate bill does address the current system’s failure to provide tax credit for childcare for the people most in need. Making the CDCTC refundable and increasing allowable expenses is a huge step in improving child care assistance for low-income families.


  1. Michael Bindner  ::  6:20 pm on July 28th, 2014:

    Some states, mostly blue, are making pre-K free for all children. If the tax is refundable, then it could be used to change withholding and maybe even pay negative withholding (indeed, the entire social benefit sector could be one large refundable tax cut paid with wages. Let us also note that this credit goes to people who have to go to work, depriving their kids of mommy or daddy time when it is most crucial. The real option would be to restore Welfare so that single parents can stay home until their children are in pre-K (and if needed, send them to school themsleves after that) while putting in a refundable tax credit for stay-at-home parents on their spouse’s taxes. This idea that both parents should work is nasty hold-over from the twentieth century. That men must be the workers is a sad holdover from patriarchy that is the biggest factor in continuing the glass ceiling as any other. Until feminism champions stay at home dads, it will continue to fail. As a sometime stay at home Dad (with a disability who can’t get the benefit), gettng a tax credit would have helped both financially and in other ways. The old Child Care Credit, if the cost was high, would be a welcome way to get money back once I went back to work – but the decision to go back to work was whether my weekly pay was less than my child care expense. For me, it was. If it is not, the second parent should stay home – and many used to.

  2. The Real Reason Obamacare Is Now In Trouble | TheAllNews  ::  6:58 am on July 29th, 2014:

    […] The cost, though, is that indirect programs are hard to design well. They create a lot of complexity for users—these programs are a big part of why doing your taxes is such a pain. And they sometimes fail to get dollars where they are most needed. […]

  3. chloe wigs by euronext 100  ::  2:11 pm on August 11th, 2014:

    Malpresentations (breech or other positions other than head down).
    Tanning requires that you sit, stand or lay still – this could get boring.
    Why Sunless Spray Tanning is a Safer Alternative During Pregnancy.

    my site: chloe wigs by euronext 100

  4. plastic surgeons in florida  ::  10:56 pm on August 12th, 2014:

    When one hear the term plastic surgery, the first thing come into mind that it is related to a
    star (TV or movie actor) who trying to delay the effects of aging.
    Sometimes, our decisions could be clouded by pressure from our surroundings.
    By changing the size & shape of the nose,
    this cosmetic nose can positively influence the balance of facial features.

    my blog post plastic surgeons in florida

  5. general adult Add symptoms checklist  ::  7:41 am on August 17th, 2014:

    Its leading character іs based on Eugene’ѕ tragic yett infinitely romantic
    eldr brother Jamie, who also dominates the.
    “The list of people below are all members of the 27 club, having been musicians that died at the age of twenty seven. It is a fusion of popular dance musics from the West such as jazz, soul, Latin, and rock blended with sabar, the traditional drumming and dance music of Senegal.

    my website; general adult Add sƴmptoms checklist

  6. visite el documento hasta que viene  ::  11:05 pm on August 19th, 2014:

    visite el documento hasta que viene

    TaxVox » Blog Archive The “Helping Working Families Afford Child Care Act” Would Help, but Doesn’t Solve the Timing Mismatch » TaxVox

  7. hcg weight loss injections online  ::  3:03 pm on August 20th, 2014:

    Actually, the correct term is “nausea and vomiting of pregnancy”.
    However, there are numerous HCG recipes that exist, thanks to the thousands of people who’ve bravely undertaken this diet.
    Using his research Simeons began a strict diet regimen coupled with injections of the HCG hormone.

    My weblog hcg weight loss injections online

  8. please click the next document  ::  1:39 pm on August 26th, 2014:

    please click the next document

    TaxVox » Blog Archive The “Helping Working Families Afford Child Care Act” Would Help, but Doesn’t Solve the Timing Mismatch » TaxVox

  9. free gardening advice  ::  9:25 pm on August 27th, 2014:

    free gardening advice

    TaxVox » Blog Archive The “Helping Working Families Afford Child Care Act” Would Help, but Doesn’t Solve the Timing Mismatch » TaxVox

  10. fort lauderdale plumbers eemax sp2412 repair parts  ::  3:40 pm on September 1st, 2014:

    Your small appliances can remain hidden in these shelves and still be easily accessible.
    In fact, drain problems also occurs during heavy continuous
    rains or storms. So wiping water into the sink and cleaning up
    is quicker.

    Feel free to visit my website :: fort lauderdale plumbers eemax sp2412 repair parts

  11. Laser hair growth treatment for women  ::  7:07 pm on September 4th, 2014:

    Article Source: more information on how to regrow
    your hair check out Total Hair Regrowth Review. Purchase shampoo
    or other hair care products that are meant specifically for people with thinning
    hair. Any cosmetic plastic procedure could be a worthwhile and extraordinary experience for both the
    patient and surgeon, if this is done in the light of surgical standards in term of safety.

    my web-site; Laser hair growth treatment for women

  12. please click the next site  ::  11:07 pm on September 5th, 2014:

    please click the next site


  13. marine bait freezer  ::  1:04 pm on September 6th, 2014:

    I was at first shocked and then giddy with excitement as I went and started catching hoppers.

    Adding a pinch of baking soda to tomato sauce will reduce the acidity.
    Fishing Lures For Sale:- The next time you’re rummaging through the garden shed it’s worth taking a long, hard look
    at that old tackle box.

    My web blog marine bait freezer

  14. browse around this web-site  ::  5:10 pm on September 6th, 2014:

    browse around this web-site


  15. related  ::  11:00 am on September 8th, 2014:



  16. laser hair growth therapy cost  ::  3:07 am on September 11th, 2014:

    This herbal solution will help you achieve picture perfect hair once more.
    main light based permanent hair removal technique for men. However, pulling on a scab that was adherent to the skin usually
    dislodged the graft – often several days after
    pulling on a hair was safe.

    Also visit my blog … laser hair growth therapy cost

  17. spanish Fly effects Video  ::  11:19 pm on September 15th, 2014:

    If you are going for most excellent contents like myself, just pay a quick visit this
    web page every day because it offers quality contents, thanks

  18. more information  ::  4:19 am on September 17th, 2014:

    more information


  19. Angelina  ::  1:29 pm on September 19th, 2014:

    This website was… how do you say it? Relevant!!
    Finally I have found something that helped me.

    Thanks a lot!

    Look into my blog … genital herpes testing nyc (Angelina)

  20. spray tanning salons in daytona beach  ::  2:19 am on September 20th, 2014:

    Other symptoms can include but are not limited to
    irritability and mood swings, hot flashes and night sweats, memory
    lapses, aching joints, depression, weight gain, and
    pelvic pain. You can keep your spray tan longer
    by using products that will not only preserve its color but also enhances it.
    Exfoliating removes the dead skin cells, which means that the tanner will dye the
    skin which is likely to last for a far longer period of time.

    Check out my web site – spray tanning salons in daytona beach

  21. mouse click the up coming website  ::  1:36 am on September 21st, 2014:

    mouse click the up coming website


  22. Eminem  ::  9:33 pm on October 2nd, 2014:

    Thanks for the auspicious writeup. It actually was once a enjoyment account it.
    Glance complicated to far introduced agreeable from you!
    However, how could we keep in touch?

  23.  ::  10:27 pm on October 20th, 2014:

    Hi it’s me, I am also visiting this website regularly, this site is
    genuinely pleasant and the viewers are actually sharing good thoughts.

  24. life Insurance coral Springs  ::  9:50 pm on October 30th, 2014:

    Hi! I could have sworn I’ve been to this blog before but after checking through some of the post I realized it’s new to me.
    Nonetheless, I’m definitely glad I found it and I’ll be bookmarking and checking back