The Bring Jobs Home Act Won’t

By :: July 24th, 2014

The Bring Jobs Home Act is a classic message bill. Its Democratic sponsors have no interest in making it law, they merely see it as a way to boost the party’s Senate candidates in part by forcing Republicans to vote against something that sounds like a good idea. After all, who could be against bringing jobs home?

Trouble is, this bill would do almost nothing to "bring jobs home." It combines two ineffectual ideas into a single bill, and the whole is no more than the sum of its exceedingly modest parts.

The measure aims to do two things: Reward U.S. firms with a 20 percent tax credit for relocating business units from overseas to the U.S. and punishing firms by denying a tax deduction for the cost of relocating operations from the U.S. to foreign countries. “It protects American jobs and encourages future job creation within our borders,” Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid said on Tuesday.

Actually, it wouldn’t.

The ideas in this bill, or variations on their themes, have been floating around the policy world for years and have rarely gotten traction. At first glance the measure looks a bit like an employment subsidy, and its title certainly implies that it is. But look closely, and this bill is quite different. It doesn't subsidize firms that create U.S. jobs at all. Rather, it rewards them for merely moving business units to the U.S.

In the past, lawmakers promoted tax incentives to encourage hiring as a way to help reverse economic slumps (The theory: hiring more people would increase demand which would encourage more hiring).

Such a measure was enacted during the Carter years. For an insider’s take on what happened, read Emil Sunley, who was a top Treasury official at the time. Len Burman helpfully dug out Emil’s comments in a blog back in 2009 when the Obama Administration was toying with a similar idea.(For a contrary—and more positive view—of the Carter bill, you can read another Tax Vox blog and its comments here).

But unlike that measure, this bill does not link the credit to the actual number of new jobs created in the U.S. Rather it allows firms to take a credit against such costs as permit, license, and brokerage fees, or the cost of installing equipment. Unlike the older-style jobs bills, this one does not provide tax subsidies to offset labor costs. And to qualify for the subsidy, firms must only show some increase in domestic jobs. If I read the bill correctly, one new job will do.

Presumably, a U.S. firm could move a business unit to the U.S, take the credit, and then open new production facilities in China.

For many multinationals, the credit would be largely meaningless. Those firms already pay close to a zero U.S. tax rate thanks to their ability to shift income to low-tax countries. With their U.S. tax liability already low, the credit would do almost nothing to encourage them to shift operations to the U.S.

The penalty side of this bill--disallowing deductions for the costs of moving production overseas-- would be similarly ineffective. The costs of such a move are normally trivial: Firms build new factories, they don’t hoist existing U.S. plants onto container ships and trundle them off to China.

The Joint Committee on Taxation figures the credit would add about $360 million to the deficit over 10 years, while disallowing the deduction would reduce the deficit by about $143 million over a decade—an indication of how small an impact it is likely to have on corporate behavior.

Finally, remember that this bill would do nothing whatever to stop the latest wave of corporate inversions. A U.S. firm that reincorporates as a foreign entity to reduce its taxes is changing a mailing address on some legal documents, not moving jobs. Deductible costs are trivial compared to tax savings.

Democrats have tried this bill before. A couple of years ago, Michigan senator Debbie Stabenow proposed a similar measure with White House backing. This time the sponsor is Montana’s John Walsh. But the idea has gotten no better with age.



  1. Edilizia Libera  ::  9:58 pm on July 24th, 2014:

    Excellent blog you have here but I was curious if you knew of any
    community forums that cover the same topics discussed in this article?
    I’d really love to be a part of community where I
    can get feed-back from other experienced people that share the
    same interest. If you have any suggestions, please let me know.
    Appreciate it!

  2. Michael Bindner  ::  4:22 am on July 25th, 2014:

    The Senate bill is an interesting statement, although I don’t know if it is aimed at the jobless or the “job creators” who have money to spend for the campaign season. I would much rather see a 20% VAT replacing at least some of personal and corporate income taxes than a 20% credit for mutli-nationals bringing jobs to America.

  3. Sandra White  ::  9:38 pm on July 27th, 2014:

    Very interesting points you have mentioned , appreciate it for posting . “These days an income is something you can’t live without–or within.” by Tom Wilson.

  4. Barbi  ::  10:26 pm on August 19th, 2014:

    Deadly accurate answer. You’ve hit the buyelels!

  5. Análisis completo Aprende más Aprende Más Aquí Aquí la respuesta Artículo completo blog aquí Bonus click aquí Click en este link Click Here click para ir a la fuente Clickando aquí Consigue Más Info Consigue Más Información contenido de utilid  ::  11:02 pm on August 19th, 2014:

    Análisis completo Aprende más Aprende Más Aquí Aquí la respuesta Artículo completo blog aquí Bonus click aquí Click en este link Click Here click para ir a la fuente Clickando aquí Consigue Más Info Consigue Más Información contenido de utilidad cont…

    TaxVox » Blog Archive The Bring Jobs Home Act won’t

  6. homes for sale in dallas texas  ::  12:54 am on August 20th, 2014:

    Excellent blog right here! Also your site so much up
    fast! What host are you the use of? Can I am getting your associate link on your host?
    I wish my website loaded up as fast as yours lol

    Feel free to visit my weblog :: homes for sale in dallas texas

  7.  ::  9:06 pm on September 6th, 2014:

    If you would like to increase your knowledge simply keep visiting
    this site and be updated with the most recent gossip posted here.

    My web page :: basement bathroom remodeling;,

  8. please click the following page  ::  11:31 am on September 21st, 2014:

    please click the following page

    The Bring Jobs Home Act won’t

  9. ขายห้องน้ำสำเร็จรูป  ::  9:12 pm on September 24th, 2014:

    Hello there! I know this is somewhat off topic but I
    was wondering which blog platform are you using for this site?
    I’m getting fed up of WordPress because I’ve had problems with hackers and I’m looking at options for another
    platform. I would be great if you could point me in the direction of a
    good platform.

  10.  ::  9:33 pm on September 24th, 2014:

    The Bring Jobs Home Act won’t

  11. normal heart rate  ::  12:18 am on September 26th, 2014:

    Hey, I think your blog might be having browser compatibility issues.
    When I look at your website in Chrome, it looks fine but when opening
    in Internet Explorer, it has some overlapping. I just wanted to
    give you a quick heads up! Other then that, terrific blog!

  12. $18.99  ::  7:21 pm on October 1st, 2014:

    It’s nearly impossible to find experienced people on this subject, but you sound like you know what you’re talking about!


  13. eating foods  ::  12:29 am on October 4th, 2014:

    Yes! Finally something about side effect.

  14. Frank  ::  6:30 am on October 29th, 2014:

    You could possibly get exclusive bonuses by orrering early.
    There are a lot of games out there, but not all of them are good.
    The biggest problem with such a system is that there is little roomm for public

    Feel free to surf too my web-site … clash of clans triche, Frank,

  15. cheap life insurance  ::  8:53 am on February 14th, 2015:

    You’re the one with the brains here. I’m watching for your posts.

  16. priligy on line  ::  7:00 pm on February 14th, 2015:

    No question this is the place to get this info, thanks y’all.

  17. order prednisone from us pharmacies no prescrition  ::  7:39 pm on February 14th, 2015:

    I had no idea how to approach this before-now I’m locked and loaded.