Utah Lets Same-Sex Couples File Joint Tax Returns

By :: January 17th, 2014

The Utah State Tax Commission yesterday reversed Governor Gary Herbert (R), ruling that same-sex couples may file their 2013 state tax returns as married, as long as they wed before the end of last year. The ruling also applies to couples who married in other jurisdictions.

As I discussed in my last TaxVox post, the governor ordered state agencies to ignore same-sex marriages performed in Utah during the brief period they were allowed under court order. When U.S. Attorney General Eric Holder subsequently ruled that those couples could file joint federal tax returns, tax filing became more complicated for affected couples.

The tax commission’s reversal undoes those complications in Utah, at least for 2013. Utah thus joins Oregon and Colorado, states that do not recognize same-sex marriages but nonetheless allow same-sex couples to file joint state tax returns if they file joint federal returns.

The situation in Utah could be short-lived. The tax commission emphasized that their ruling applies only to 2013 tax returns. Utah has appealed the judicial decision that allowed same-sex marriages in the state. If the decision is reversed, marriages performed during the brief period they were allowed could simply evaporate.

The tax commission promised couples who file joint returns based on the ruling that they would “not be subject to penalties for any tax deficiencies resulting solely from following this guidance.” If the appeals courts rule against them, those couples might have to amend their 2013 state tax returns—and possibly federal too—but at least they wouldn’t incur penalties.

But that outcome would leave a glaring inconsistency: the state is now on record as recognizing same-sex marriages performed outside of Utah but (assuming appeals courts agree) it constitutionally wouldn’t allow such marriages to occur in the state. That suggests that Utahns in same-sex relationships could marry outside the state and Utah would treat them as married, at least as far as state taxes are concerned.

The Supreme Court ruled last summer in U.S. v. Windsor that the federal government could not refuse to recognize same-sex marriages. In dissent, Justice Antonin Scalia wrote that the court had left “the second, state-law shoe to be dropped later, maybe next Term.” Until the Supreme Court drops that second shoe, we’ll likely watch states and lower courts stumble their ways toward workable and lasting solutions.

8Comments

  1. Michael Bindner  ::  3:55 pm on January 17th, 2014:

    As I stated earlier this week, the second state law shoe will surely drop – right on the head of the Utah governor. State and local officials more and more are taking seriously their oaths to support and defend the US Constitution – and that increasingly includes people’s right to marriage regardless of sexual orientation. The politicos who are following their hard right funders will be steam rolled by the patriotism of unelected government. As for why Scalia was able to remark on the other shoe not dropping, it was because that matter was not at issue. Had it been, both shoes would have dropped. I suspect that Scalia has not long to wait to write another few dissents on gay marriage.

  2. An Addendum to the Prior Note re: Same-Sex Marriage in Utah | What We Pay for Civilized Society  ::  11:18 pm on January 17th, 2014:

    […] This is actually a really big deal: Utah is the third state, after Colorado and Oregon, that doesn’t recognize same-sex marriage but allows couples who […]

  3. Tax Roundup, 1/20/14: If it’s not a scandal, it hurts like one. And: S corporation ESOP play in WSJ. « Roth & Company, P.C  ::  10:20 am on January 20th, 2014:

    […] Roberton Williams, Utah Lets Same-Sex Couples File Joint Tax Returns (TaxVox) […]

  4. http://serveurminecraftgratuit.fr  ::  1:21 am on April 10th, 2014:

    There are again tons of options when you are in a multiplayer server.
    Your shelter has to only be very good sufficient to cover you
    until the next day, so it’s not essential that it be massive.
    Given Microsoft’s relationship with 4J Studios, it is a safe bet that Minecraft PS3 Edition will be released the same day or
    just after the Xbox One Edition.

    Review my blog post … http://serveurminecraftgratuit.fr

  5. Jennabel  ::  5:26 pm on August 19th, 2014:

    Your answer lifts the intecligenle of the debate.

  6. levitra  ::  11:42 pm on February 12th, 2015:

    Yup, that’ll do it. You have my appreciation.

  7. cheap levitra 25mg pills  ::  6:27 pm on February 14th, 2015:

    I told my kids we’d play after I found what I needed. Damnit.

  8. Craig  ::  12:23 am on February 22nd, 2015:

    Weekend Sneak Peek 19 August 2012 Sneak Peek Ariel and Dan’s wedding was just plain fun to progothaph! Here is one photo from their day… Contact