Taxing Bitcoin

By :: January 7th, 2014

By now most everyone has heard of bitcoin. But exactly what is it? And how should it be taxed?

Bitcoin is usually described as virtual currency. That’s useful shorthand, but is it really money? And should it be taxed as if it is? Or is it a capital asset? How about a commodity? And then there is the matter of using this quasi-cash to avoid taxes and regulation altogether.

The IRS says it is studying the matter but has yet to issue any guidance. Until it does, it is anyone’s guess how bitcoin should be taxed. Most users/investors will simply pick what is most beneficial to them when they file their 2013 returns.

At the moment, bitcoin and its cousin currencies have had far more success generating buzz than facilitating commerce. Yet, the idea of online money can’t be ignored.

Curiously, the motivating force for the IRS to issue guidance may be an effort by Cameron and Tyler Winklevoss (best known until now for their legal battle with Mark Zuckerberg over Facebook) to create an exchange-traded fund to track bitcoin prices. The twins are awaiting SEC approval for their ETF but their very request raises important tax policy questions that need to be answered.

Back in November, Mindi Lowy and Miriam Abraham of PriceWaterhouseCoopers wrote a terrific review of the current state of play for Tax Notes Today (requires a subscription).  They concluded that for now virtual currency would probably be viewed as a capital asset since it has limited use as real money. However, should these vehicles gain wider commercial acceptance, they’d more likely be treated as actual currency for tax and regulatory purposes.

The distinctions are not trivial.

If bitcoin is a capital asset (the Winkelvoss ETF would treat it that way), long-term gains and losses would be subject to preferential capital gains rates (23.8 percent for high-income taxpayers). However, losses of more than $3,000 could only be used to offset other gains and not ordinary income. Separate rules may apply to professional traders

What if bitcoin is a currency for tax purposes, the same as, say a euro? In that case, profits from sales would be taxed as ordinary income, with a top rate of 39.6 percent, though all losses could offset other income.

Either way, the mere act of buying something would likely be a taxable event. As Lowy and Abraham note, this would be something of a surprise to consumers.

Similarly, mining bitcoin (the process of obtaining the currency by solving a math problem) would also trigger tax. Taxing bitcoin would also require users to track cost basis—not so easy at the moment, although Bloomberg has begun publishing prices.

Then there is the matter of using virtual currency to avoid all tax—as well as other laws. Last Thursday, the Wall Street Journal’s Danny Yadron wrote a fascinating piece about Cody Wilson, the guy who made himself famous by posting online instructions for making plastic guns from 3-D printers. Wilson says he is working on software called Dark Wallet that would defeat the government’s ability electronically track bitcoin transactions. While Wilson and others see this as a Libertarian protection against government, others see it as simply a way to make it easier for people to deal illegal drugs or evade taxes.

For now, bitcoin is little more than a marketing fad, an ideological metaphor, and a sandbox for speculators. But virtual currency isn’t likely to go away. It would be useful if users didn’t have to guess at its tax treatment.

13Comments

  1. TaxVox – BitCoin Razor  ::  12:30 am on January 8th, 2014:

    […] Source […]

  2. Michael Bindner  ::  2:50 am on January 8th, 2014:

    Bitcoins would not be subject to capital gains taxes – although if they are lent to an online bank at interest, that interest would be taxable, probably at normal interest rates (although if invested it the bitcoin returns would be taxable as dividends – with the issuer of the dividend liable for reporting said gain. Indeed, for sales and income (or VAT) purposes, it is not the holder of the bitcoin that is liable to report (and collect) the tax, it is the seller or employer. In other words, it is simply currency. When internet sales tax legislation is finalized, bitcoin transactions would be subject to tax. Employers are always subject to issue a 1099 or W2 and in the latter perform withholding. There are penalties for not doing both (excepting, of course, 1099 contract transactions which fall below certain limits). Bitcoin income taxes would be accounted for on your 1040 in the same way that other income is – likely with the same penalties for evasion. Of course, bitcoins earned in games and spend online as well could be considered trafficking in monopoly money if this is their only use (rather than in buying real goods, say on Amazon).

  3. Virtual Mining Bitcoin News » Big Ideas: On Christie's mess, suburbanites and Bitcoin  ::  12:30 pm on January 17th, 2014:

    […] Gleckman for the Tax Policy Center’s Tax Vox: Bitcoin is usually described as virtual currency. That’s useful shorthand, but is it really […]

  4. Chris Farrell Membership make money work from home, online business, income online, internet marketing, list building, email marketing,  ::  12:20 am on January 18th, 2014:

    Making income online via internet marketing is the fastest way and can be learn’t at the Chris Farrell membership.

  5. make money by various stuff  ::  12:42 am on January 18th, 2014:

    Pretty terrific publish. I just became aware of ones weblog along with desired to declare that I have seriously relished looking your blog page content. After all I will be registering to a person’s nourish and that i i do hope you generate all over again as soon as possible!

  6. Fastest online Marketing business  ::  7:48 pm on February 1st, 2014:

    Highly energetic post, I liked that a lot.
    Will there be a part 2?

  7. You Could Owe Capital Gains Taxes When You Spend Bitcoin  ::  2:02 am on March 29th, 2014:

    […] This means Bitcoin transactions will be taxed as capital gains, not as ordinary income. But, perhaps surprisingly, the act of spending Bitcoin could trigger capital gains taxes. Thus, the use of virtual currencies […]

  8. high volume bitcoin mixer  ::  1:32 am on April 1st, 2014:

    How are you better than knowing that “bitcion”. Bitcoin the best in my opinion. If you want to make the catch and want to good things about the tour High Volume Bitcoin Mixer we come here for more information.

  9. home  ::  6:43 pm on August 9th, 2014:

    Wow, superb blog layout! How long have you been blogging for? you made blogging look easy. The overall look of your website is wonderful, as well as the content!|

  10. ltc gear discount  ::  9:32 am on September 29th, 2014:

    Excellent article, seriously enjoyed reading through it all.
    I have posted on Facebook, You should submit much more articles like this!

  11. can i earn money home  ::  10:39 am on October 5th, 2014:

    Hey there! Do you use Twitter? I’d like to follow
    you if that would be okay. I’m undoubtedly enjoying your blog
    and look forward to new updates.

  12. Best Bitcoin Casino  ::  8:42 pm on October 11th, 2014:

    Let’s face bitcoin it – intermediaries do it, too. You become part of any government or banking regulator, the way things are happening!

  13. fantasy basketball  ::  1:03 pm on October 15th, 2014:

    Having read this I believed it was very enlightening. I appreciate you spending some time and energy to put this information together. I once again find myself personally spending way too much time both reading and commenting. But so what, it was still worthwhile!