Court of Appeals Finds a Trade or Business: Could this Mean Higher Taxes for Private Equity?

By :: July 25th, 2013

The First Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals ruled yesterday that private equity funds are engaged in a trade or business under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA).  The court said the case, Sun Capital Partners v. New England Teamsters & Trucking, “presented important issues of first impression.”   And the court’s resolution of the trade or business issue now may open the door to much higher taxes for private equity funds and their investors. 

In a unanimous decision, the First Circuit rejected the district court’s finding that private equity funds are merely “passive” investors, which is the position that nearly all private equity funds take for tax purposes.  Under a typical fund’s partnership agreement, the fund must avoid engaging in a trade or business for Federal income tax purposes. 

However, the First Circuit concluded that private equity funds that actively manage the operations of their portfolio companies are engaged in a trade or business.  It does not matter whether a fund has employees or offices, or if its management company has the employees and offices.  The key is whether the fund’s activities (including those of its management company) exceed those of a typical investor.  That extra effort, of course, is the essence of private equity business and is used to justify the huge fees the funds charge their investors.  

While the decision in Sun Capital means that private equity funds may be liable for unfunded pension liabilities of their portfolio companies, it potentially has much broader tax implications that are critical for private equity funds and their investors.  For tax exempt or foreign investors, income from a private equity fund that is engaged in a trade or business is potentially subject to the unrelated business income tax (UBIT) or withholding taxes, respectively.  Moreover the decision buttresses the argument that the income of private equity managers should be taxed at higher ordinary income rates, rather than capital gains rates.  For more detail on this argument take a look at Tax Vox blogs here  and here.

Now may be a good time for private equity funds, their managers, investors, and advisers to reexamine their tax position.

12Comments

  1. Michael Bindner  ::  11:49 pm on July 25th, 2013:

    I am glad they could do what Congress could not. Of course, as a result of this decision, there will likely be clarifying legislation to undo some of it – but mostly accept it as part of the tax code. The real equality question is still regarding caps on Social Security taxes – not necessarily on the employee contribution side (which would simply increase benefits if the caps were raised), but on the employer contribution side – which could be funded by a consumption tax (rather than an HI payroll tax that includes non-wage income) while crediting contributions equally to each worker – regardless of their wage.

  2. STEVEN J. FROMM, ATTORNEY, LL.M. (TAXATION)  ::  11:59 am on July 27th, 2013:

    wow! This is a very significant tax case with some very large tax implications. It looks like the equated this to passive versus active real estate investors. In any event, this case bears watching very closely. Thanks for the post.

  3. James McGill  ::  12:02 am on July 28th, 2013:

    Pension liabilities seems to be increasing after the results of the Sun Capital Partners verdict. Thanks for pointing it out. It is very useful information.

  4. Will the Sun Capital Case Transform Private Equity?  ::  10:01 am on August 6th, 2013:

    […] respectively;” foreign LPs may also face federal and state taxes. For GPs, profits could now be potentially taxed as ordinary income, instead of capital gains. In an already tax-sensitive environment, increased taxes on both the LP […]

  5. funny shirts for guys uk  ::  5:43 pm on August 6th, 2013:

    A huge outdated tree did not make it by means of today.
    1/3 on the tree fell across our road earlier today.

  6. zombie shower curtain thinkgeek  ::  4:27 am on August 7th, 2013:

    could be a fantastic time to ask. Carrie Gouldin (that is definitely me)
    will talk about social media and how we test not to suck at
    it. InterventionCon hosts a wide array of discussions and internet meme-osity and even if
    you

  7. Camp Defines Private Equity as a Business, Would Boost Taxes on Carried Interest  ::  2:03 am on March 1st, 2014:

    […] law.  One example:  tomorrow, the U.S. Supreme Court will review a request that it consider a pension case called Sun Capital Partners v. New England Teamsters & Trucking, a dispute that may also turn […]

  8. gay porn  ::  3:11 pm on June 19th, 2014:

    Its like you read my mind! You appear to know a lot about this, like you
    wrote the book in it or something. I think that you could do with a few
    pics to drive the message home a little bit, but instead of that, this is
    wonderful blog. A great read. I will definitely be back.

    Here is my blog … gay porn

  9. https://publipage.zendesk.com  ::  10:09 am on July 2nd, 2014:

    What’s up Dear, are you truly visiting this website on a regular basis, if so afterward you will absolutely
    take pleasant knowledge.

  10. Hudson  ::  3:31 am on July 16th, 2014:

    It is advised to invest money in buying the e-cig was big, it is free of various harmful chemicals andd noxioous smoke that make smoking unpleasant.
    Without charging the instrument will not work which is obvious enough.
    Though of course thgis is only for the nicotine and tar
    electronic cigarettes reviews that are present in the water container.

    The higher nicotine strength you have the privilege to get disposable e-cigarettes for a considerably
    smal amount of ground herbal material. Thus, vaporizer is always safe to use in building your vaporizer.

    Loook at my ebsite … what are vape pens used for (Hudson)

  11. search  ::  5:19 am on September 22nd, 2014:

    Amazing blog! Is your theme custom made or did you download it
    from somewhere? A theme like yours with a few
    simple adjustements would really make my blog jump out.
    Please let me know where you got your design.
    Thanks

    my blog – search

  12. pricenis.ru  ::  9:18 am on September 23rd, 2014:

    Unlike Army Ants, Leaf-divider Ants are normal and easy
    to find inside the Peruvian Amazon.