Romney 2.0: Generous Tax Cuts, But How Will He Pay for Them?

By :: March 1st, 2012

The Tax Policy Center has updated its analysis of Mitt Romney’s platform to reflect his proposed new tax cuts. And the result: Lower taxes for nearly everyone. The highest-income households would pay significantly less, while few with the lowest incomes would benefit.  And without offsetting revenue increases or new spending cuts, Romney’s plan would significantly increase the budget deficit.

Romney’s initial tax plan was blasted by many Republicans as too cautious, so last week he rolled out a far more ambitious proposal. Instead of simply making the 2001/2003 tax cuts permanent , abolishing the estate tax,  eliminating taxes on investment income for those making less than $200,000, and cutting corporate tax rates,  Romney threw the long ball.

On top of his original plan, Romney proposed cutting all ordinary income tax rates by 20 percent and eliminating the Alternative Minimum Tax. While Romney said he’d offset the lost revenue from these new tax cuts by trimming deductions, credits, and exclusions, he did not say how. 

The cost of the new Romney plan? For 2015, when changes would be fully effective, he’d add nearly $500 billion to the budget deficit, even after extending the 2001/2003/2010 tax cuts. If the tax cuts are allowed to expire, he’d add $900 billion to the deficit in 2015.

Two caveats: First, Romney has not described how he’d broaden the tax base, thus TPC could only score his proposed tax cuts.  Second, on Wednesday TPC released 10-year revenue projections for two changes Romney added to his plan—the across-the-board rate cut and repeal of the AMT.  Those estimates are very different, in part because they only included two elements of his plan. This projection—for one year rather than 10—looks at his entire proposal. 

Romney aides also say high-income households would pay about the same share of taxes under his new system as they would if he extended the 2001/2003 tax cuts. But, without those unidentified revenue increases, they would pay a considerably lower share.  

For instance, those making $1 million or more would enjoy an average tax cut of  8 percent of income or roughly $250,000 (relative to a world where the Bush/Obama tax cuts remain in place) compared to an average cut of less than 4 percent of income, or $2,900, for all households. Because Romney would repeal President Obama’s 2009 tax cuts, those making less than $10,000 would pay an average of $100 more in taxes and only about 11 percent would get any tax cut at all.

Romney would cut taxes for nearly all households making between $50,000 and $75,000 but by far less than those with higher incomes. On average, those making $1 million or more would see their after-tax incomes rise by nearly 12 percent while incomes of households earning $50,000-$75,000 would rise by only about 2 percent.

Romney’s promise to make his new system as progressive as today’s puts him in a difficult policy box. Which tax preferences aimed at upper-income households could he dump to keep the code progressive while not adding hundreds of billions to the deficit?   

Raising rates on capital gains and dividends might help, but he’s already promised to cut them to zero for those making $200,000 or less and hold them at 15 percent for everyone else. Eliminating or restructuring tax breaks for retirement savings, mortgage interest, and employer-sponsored health insurance could make Romney’s low-rate system more progressive, but these changes would be hugely controversial. Besides, while they’d target many of the merely rich, they wouldn’t matter much to the uber-wealthy who benefit most from Romney’s rate cuts.

Romney seems to be trying to walk a fine line between responsible fiscal policy and pandering to his base. But by not identifying how he’d pay for his generous tax cuts, his tightrope is getting pretty wobbly.

 

11Comments

  1. Michael Bindner  ::  4:00 pm on March 1st, 2012:

    While he can say he is holding the capital gains and dividend rates at 15%, unless he does it as a temorary extension, he needs 60 GOP votes to back his play. It is more likely that the Democrats will keep the Senate, which means his tax plan is DOA. Any compromise will look like the Tax Policy Center or Simpson Bowles draft, which may be enacted sooner than later. I suspect that once he gets the nomination, he will provide more detail on cuts. I also suspect that he will sign whatever bipartisan compromise is worked out in Congress.

  2. Jack B  ::  8:11 am on March 2nd, 2012:

    Just a thought on individual tax expenditures.
    “Eliminating or restructuring tax breaks for retirement savings”
    Should this expenditure be lumped in with all the others?
    In effect it is a deferral of spending not a complete write off. Also, any growth will eventually be taxed.

  3. Zach H  ::  9:07 am on March 2nd, 2012:

    It’s not that he’s “not identifying how he’d pay for his generous tax cuts.” It’s that he’s got no plan to pay for his generous tax cuts. His tax policy documents present his marginal rate cuts, corporate tax cuts, capital gains cuts, elimination of the AMT and estate tax, and transition to territorial taxation as things we should do tomorrow.

    The document on his website called “Tax Policy” only lists base-broadening reform under “Long-Term Goal: Pursue a Fairer, Flatter, Simpler Tax Structure.” His plans are clear, so take him at his word: tax cuts immediately after election and maybe he’ll increase revenues in the future. Of course, doing so would require that he break his pledge to never make any change in law that raises revenue, but I’m sure he’ll have an explanation as to how this is all perfectly consistent and Reaganesque.

    Similarly, his document says, “Washington’s problem is not too little revenue, but rather too much spending.” The only spending cuts he’s committed to are axing Obamacare (associated with an equally large drop in revenue) and cutting Medicaid. Rather than wondering what Romney really means, it’s probably better to just summarize his plan as: “Cut taxes for the richest half of America. Cut them even more for people making over 200 thousand a year and more yet for millionaires. Save money by cutting Medicaid and pay for the rest by increasing the debt. Also, give Paris Hilton a tax cut on her dad’s money and let Mitt Romney sell his stocks in the Caymans tax free.”

    I think that’s a totally fair summary. Romney’s free to come up with a better plan and let us know what it is.

  4. Romney tax plan: Soaring debt, huge breaks for rich | My Blog  ::  12:40 pm on March 2nd, 2012:

    […] Tax Policy Center has run an research of Mitt Romney’s many recent, updated tax-reform proposal. Its conclusion? “Lower taxes for scarcely everyone. The highest-income households would compensate significantly […]

  5. Romney tax plan: Soaring debt, huge breaks for rich | High technology News  ::  2:37 am on March 15th, 2012:

    […] Tax Policy Center has run an research of Mitt Romney’s many recent, updated tax-reform proposal. Its conclusion? “Lower taxes for scarcely everyone. The highest-income households would compensate significantly […]

  6. nick  ::  12:56 pm on March 29th, 2012:

    Romney will become more flexible after the election just like Obama will be more flexible with nuclear weapons after the election. DO Y’ALL NOT SEE THE COMPARISONS? These men are putty in the hands on International interests. They don’t care about the average american taxpayer being swallowed by debt and devalued currency.

  7. clarks  ::  8:44 pm on April 26th, 2012:

    Since their humble beginning back in 1825 Clarks shoes has built upon their reputation for quality by continuously revolutionizing the comfort footwear industry.From their inception,the Clarks brand has been synonymous with comfort,quality and style.Utilizing a wide range of high quality leathers and a surprisingly fresh approach to shoe design,Clarks continues to offer a broad range of fashionable shoe styles for both clarks mens shoes and clarks women shoes.Whether your looking for a casual leather flip flop,a unique slide,or comfortable casual dress shoe Clarks is sure to have the right style for you.

    As always,Clarks uk shoes continues to use only the finest leather,suede and nubuck in each and every shoe.Recently,the introduction of the unstructured series has offered consumers a number of innovative and exciting styles that utilize the Clarks Sandals exclusive Air Circulation System™.The ACS system controls the interior climate of the shoe by allowing warm air to dissipate while cool air is pulled in.Additionally,Clarks sale Unstructured shoes are thoughtfully designed to be softly cushioned and have an exceptionally lightweight flexible construction that allows you to move about more freely and naturally.

    By purchasing a pair of Clarks originals shoes you will be joining a tradition of quality,comfort and style that has stood the test of time.

  8. coast  ::  9:40 pm on April 26th, 2012:

    Coast Dresses are an excellent high street brand if you are in the market for the perfect special occasion dress.
    Whether you have a ball/prom, a black tie event, a wedding or just a special night out with the girls Coast have something suitable for all different occasions.
    Coast are one of the top brands for formal and evening occasionwear and they have several awards to prove it.The styles of Coast UK range from long maxi designs to knee length frocks to suit different evening events.
    Coast Clothes outfits are available in UK dress size 6 to 18 and a range of materials from duchess satin to silk taffeta.
    From the very start their mission has been to provide beautiful top quality Coast Dress for all the special events throughout your life,and they sure don’t disappoint.

    Coast Sale have a passion for all that is elegant,beautiful and unique.They are dedicated to creating fresh new in-house designs which enable women to look and feel glamorous.

    Coast has the collection of Coast Bridal Dresses,Coast Halter Dresses,Coast One Shoulder Dress,Coast Shoulders Dresses and Coast Strapless Dresses.

  9. Linnie  ::  11:38 pm on September 14th, 2014:

    Finally i quit my regular job, now i earn decent money online you
    should try too, just search in google – blackhand roulette system

  10. i know that girl passwords  ::  12:33 am on September 25th, 2014:

    Here are some password guidelines that should aide in the password problem.
    As a whole, this makes this type of lottery all the more attractive as the other side of winning (the most ideal scenario) involves giving back to the community (which is actually a good thing).
    There are some establishments that can use their Wi-Fi
    access point to get private information’s about you.

    My web site :: i know that girl passwords

  11. Digital playground password  ::  9:08 am on October 7th, 2014:

    ‘ Last Pass: Those who have already used this app may
    get pleased to know that its official app is now available for i – Pad as well as for i –
    Phone. Compatible with all NT-based Windows, Elcomsoft
    System Recovery can fix forgotten user and administrator passwords for Windows NT,
    2000, XP, 2003 and 2008 Server, and certainly Windows Vista passwords.
    Do you store administrative passwords in spreadsheets & flat files.

    my blog; Digital playground password